What is Shiloh about?
Shiloh is a middle-grade novel by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor, published in 1991 and winner of the 1992 Newbery Medal. It is narrated by eleven-year-old Marty Preston, who lives with his family in the rural hills of West Virginia near the small town of Friendly. One afternoon Marty encounters a young beagle who follows him home — a dog who belongs to Judd Travers, a nearby hunter who mistreats his dogs. Marty names the dog Shiloh and immediately falls in love with him. The novel follows Marty's moral struggle: he knows the dog belongs to Judd Travers, and he knows he should return him, but he also knows that Judd beats his dogs and does not care for them properly. Marty begins hiding Shiloh in a pen he has built in the hills behind his house, lying to his parents about the dog's whereabouts. When the lie unravels, Marty must find a way to keep Shiloh legally and confront the complicated reality that doing the right thing is not always simple. Shiloh was followed by two sequels, Shiloh Season and Saving Shiloh.
What genre is Shiloh?
Shiloh is middle-grade realistic fiction — a novel aimed at readers approximately eight through twelve that deals with genuine moral complexity in a way accessible to its audience. It belongs to the long tradition of boy-and-his-dog novels in American children's literature (Where the Red Fern Grows, Old Yeller, Because of Winn-Dixie), but it is distinguished from simpler versions of that tradition by its willingness to take ethics seriously: the novel does not resolve Marty's dilemma with a simple answer. It asks what to do when the law is on the side of someone who is doing wrong, when you have to lie to protect someone you love, and how a person changes when they see the world is more complicated than they thought. It is frequently taught in elementary and middle school classrooms.
How many chapters are in Shiloh?
Shiloh summary
Marty Preston is eleven years old and lives with his parents and sisters in the West Virginia hills. His family does not have much money — his father is a mail carrier — and Marty has been wanting a dog for years but knows the family cannot afford to feed one.
One afternoon Marty is walking near the Shiloh schoolhouse when a young beagle starts following him. The dog is friendly, timid, and clearly frightened of something. Marty calls him Shiloh after the place where he found him. When he brings the dog home, his father tells him the dog belongs to Judd Travers, a hunter who lives nearby, and takes Shiloh back.
Marty goes to Judd's property and watches how Judd treats his dogs: he kicks them, yells at them, gives them barely enough to eat. He does not care about them as animals — they are tools for hunting. Marty develops a deep hatred for Judd and a deep determination to keep Shiloh safe.
When Shiloh runs away from Judd and comes back to Marty, Marty hides him in a pen he builds in the hills, feeding him scraps and visiting him secretly. He lies to his parents when they ask about the dog. His mother discovers the pen but agrees to keep the secret temporarily.
The crisis comes on two fronts. First, a German shepherd breaks into Shiloh's pen and attacks him, injuring him badly. Marty has to bring the bleeding dog home and ask for help, which means confessing to his father. His father takes Shiloh to the local doctor, Doc Murphy, who treats the dog for free. Then Marty's father tells him the truth that Marty has been resisting: the dog still belongs to Judd Travers, and the right thing is to give him back.
Marty refuses to accept this. He goes to Judd and offers to work for him to pay for Shiloh. Judd initially refuses, then reluctantly agrees: if Marty works for him for twenty hours, he can have the dog. Marty works hard and fulfills the bargain.
But the novel does not let Marty off with a simple victory. During his hours of work for Judd, Marty sees Judd shoot a deer out of season. He realizes he now has something over Judd that could be used as leverage. He decides not to report Judd — partly because reporting him might cost Marty the deal for Shiloh, and partly because he has begun to understand, a little, why Judd is the way he is. The novel ends with Marty having gotten Shiloh but acknowledging the moral ambiguity of what he did: he lied, he kept secrets, he used what he knew about Judd as implicit leverage. He got what he wanted, but the world is more complicated than it looked when the story started.
How does Shiloh end?
Characters in Shiloh
Marty Preston — The narrator, eleven years old, who loves animals and cannot tolerate cruelty. His arc is from idealistic child who sees the world in simple moral terms to a boy who understands that doing right is often complicated.
Shiloh — The beagle, Marty's dog. He is a character in his own right: timid, affectionate, and in need of someone who will care for him properly.
Judd Travers — The antagonist, a hunter who mistreats his dogs. The novel is careful not to make him a simple villain: he is a man who was himself treated roughly, who has learned a certain way of dealing with the world. Marty's eventual, grudging sympathy for Judd is part of the novel's moral growth.
Mr. and Mrs. Preston — Marty's parents, who are honest, hardworking, and firm about the importance of telling the truth. His father in particular represents the position that the law is the law, even when the law is on the wrong side.
Doc Murphy — The local doctor who treats Shiloh after the German shepherd attack, providing a small example of kindness outside the family.
Quotes from Shiloh by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
Phyllis Reynolds Naylor writes Shiloh's most resonant lines in Marty's honest, unpretentious voice — a boy thinking his way through a problem that turns out to be harder than he expected.
"Nothing is as simple as you guess — not right or wrong, not Judd Travers, not even me or this dog I got here. But the good part is I saved Shiloh and opened my eyes some. Now that ain't bad for eleven."
"If Jesus ever comes back to earth again, I'm thinking, he'll come as a dog, because there isn't anything as humble or patient or loving or loyal as the dog I have in my arms right now."
"How one lie leads to another and before you know it, your whole life can be a lie."
Frequently asked questions
Did Shiloh win the Newbery Medal?
Yes. Shiloh won the Newbery Medal in 1992, which is awarded annually by the American Library Association to the author of the most distinguished contribution to American literature for children. It was Phyllis Reynolds Naylor's most celebrated book, though she had been writing children's fiction since the 1960s. The Newbery recognition brought the novel wide readership and led it to become a standard classroom text in elementary and middle school curricula. Naylor wrote two sequels — Shiloh Season (1996) and Saving Shiloh (1997) — which continue Marty and Shiloh's story.
Is Shiloh based on a true story?
Shiloh is fiction, but it was inspired by a real beagle that Phyllis Reynolds Naylor and her husband encountered during a trip to Friendly, West Virginia in the late 1980s. The dog was timid and clearly frightened, and when Naylor tried to give it some food, it trembled and cowered. The experience stayed with her and became the seed of the novel. The specific character of Judd Travers and the moral dilemma at the novel's center are invented, but the landscape and the dog's manner are drawn from observation.
What is the moral of Shiloh?
Shiloh does not offer a single, simple moral — which is part of what distinguishes it from simpler children's novels. The novel takes seriously the tension between legal ownership and ethical treatment: Shiloh belongs to Judd Travers by law, but Judd mistreats him. Marty lies repeatedly to protect Shiloh, which the novel acknowledges is wrong even as it sympathizes with his reasons. By the end, Marty has achieved what he wanted, but he has also learned that doing good often requires compromises that are hard to be proud of. The novel's moral, to the extent it has one, is that the world is complicated and that a person can do the best they can and still be left with things they are not sure were right.
What grade level is Shiloh?
Shiloh is typically assigned in grades four through six, with a reading level appropriate for ages nine through twelve. It is widely used in fourth and fifth grade classrooms as an introduction to ethical reasoning in narrative form. The novel's dialect (Marty's West Virginia vernacular) and its moral complexity make it a rich text for classroom discussion, and its length (144 pages) makes it manageable for independent reading at that age level. The Newbery Medal designation makes it a standard title in school and public library collections throughout the United States.
How does the Shiloh movie compare to the book?
The 1996 film adaptation of Shiloh, starring Blake Heron as Marty, is a straightforward and reasonably faithful adaptation of the novel. The film simplifies some of the moral complexity — particularly the scene in which Marty witnesses Judd poaching a deer — but preserves the novel's central conflict and emotional arc. A sequel film, Shiloh 2: Shiloh Season, followed in 1999. Both films are family-rated and aimed at the same middle-grade audience as the books. The films are less frequently assigned in schools than the novel, but they are often paired with the book as a comparison exercise.
What other books are similar to Shiloh?
Readers who respond to Shiloh's combination of a dog story and genuine ethical complexity often also read Kate DiCamillo's Because of Winn-Dixie (a girl and her dog in a small Florida town, with the dog as a catalyst for community), Wilson Rawls's Where the Red Fern Grows (a boy and his two hunting dogs in rural Oklahoma, with a more tragic arc), and Gary Paulsen's Hatchet (a survival story with a similarly direct, resourceful young narrator). For other middle-grade novels that take ethics seriously, Lois Lowry's Number the Stars and Christopher Paul Curtis's Bud, Not Buddy are frequently paired with Shiloh in classroom reading lists.
Related summaries
Front Desk
Kelly Yang
Front Desk is a middle-grade novel by Kelly Yang, published on May 29, 2018. It is narrated by ten-year-old Mia Tang, a recent Chinese immigrant whose family has moved to the Unite...
Tangerine
Edward Bloor
Tangerine is a young adult novel by Edward Bloor, published in 1997. It is narrated by Paul Fisher, a legally blind seventh-grader who wears thick glasses and whose vision impairme...
Thirteen Reasons Why
Jay Asher
Thirteen Reasons Why is a young adult novel by Jay Asher, published on October 18, 2007. The novel opens when Clay Jensen arrives home from school to find a box of seven cassette t...